20 Best Drugstore Eyebrow Pencils
1. Best Over-All:Maybelline Total Temptation Brow Definer Eyebrow Pencil
The Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil by Maybelline fills in the brows precisely with its teardrop-shaped applicator. It works brilliantly for light, sparse eyebrows. The fluffy spoolie is ideal for blending to create softly-defined, natural-looking eyebrows. This eyebrow pencil is available in 4 shades – blonde, soft brown, medium brown, and deep brown. Here’s an honest review of the product. Pros
Long-wearing Built-in spoolie Sweat-resistant Easy to use Does not flake Non-greasy formula Available in 4 shades
Cons None
2. Best 3-In-1 Formula:Hourglass Arch Brow Sculpting Pencil
The Hourglass Arch Brow Sculpting Pencil is an innovative, multi-dimensional powder, pencil, and wax-based formula. The triangular tip lets you create the perfect base for flawless eyebrows. This pencil also features a blending brush to help you groom your brows into perfection. Hourglass offers a range of 9 different shades to suit your desired intensity. Here’s a video featuring a detailed review of the product. Pros
3-in-1 formula No synthetic fragrances Built-in blending brush Cruelty-free Gluten-free Sulfate-free Phthalate-free GMO-free Triclosan-free Vegan No harsh chemicals No synthetic dyes Available in 9 shades
Cons None
3. Best Long-Lasting:Benefit Goof Proof Brow Pencil
The Goof Proof Brow Pencil from Benefit is available in 12 stunning shades that fill and shape your brows flawlessly. The custom tapered tip makes it easy and effortless to define your brows. The wide base helps build color with minimum strokes, and the pointed edge adds definition to the sides of your eyebrows. This video will help you understand the product better. Pros
Long-lasting Water-proof Built-in blending brush Glides on easily Available in 12 shades
Cons
Expensive
4. Best Smudge-Proof:Browluxe Precision Brow Pencil
The Browluxe Precision Brow Pencil has a range of 8 custom shades to match your natural brows perfectly. This smudge-proof brow pen features an extra-thin tip with a long edge for a powdered fill. It also has a built-in spoolie brow brush on the other end to help you groom your brows perfectly. The powder makeup tip enables natural hair-like strokes while the spoolie helps soften harsh lines for seamless blending. Pros
Available in 8 shades Long-lasting Water-proof Smudge-proof Sweat-resistant Built-in spoolie Provides buildable coverage
Cons
The tip may break off easily.
5. Best Built-In Spoolie:Chella Eyebrow Pencil
The Chella Eyebrow Pencil comes in 9 attractive shades. It provides a natural finish and has a smooth and long-wearing consistency. It glides on effortlessly and gives precise strokes without the need for a sharpener. The built-in spoolie lets you lightly blend your makeup for a more natural look. Pros
Available in 9 shades Built-in spoolie Paraben-free Gluten-free Cruelty-free
Cons
Might not last long.
6. Best For Contact Lens Wearers:L’Oreal Paris Brow Stylist Definer
The L’Oreal Brow Stylist Designer Eye Pencil uses subtle color to create soft, natural definition. On one end, you get a soft crayon tip, and on the other, a spoolie brush that is perfect for feathering. This eyebrow pencil is available in 7 shades ranging from light blonde to light brunette and soft black. Pros
Water-proof Ophthalmologist-tested Long-lasting Built-in spoolie Easy to use Available in 7 shades Suitable for contact lens wearers and sensitive eyes
Cons
Not enough product
7. Best Value For Money:Rimmel London Professional Eyebrow Pencil
The Professional Eyebrow Pencil from Rimmel London fills in gaps and enhance or refine the shape of your brows. You get fuller eyebrows without looking fake. The design is basic and newbie-friendly, with an inbuilt brow brush on the pencil cap. This eyebrow pencil comes in three shades – dark brown, hazel, and black-brown. Pros
Smudge-resistant Long-lasting Value for money Available in 3 shades
Cons
Not enough pigmentation
8. Best For Maximum Precision:Milani Stay Put Brow Sculpting Mechanical Pencil
The Milani Stay Put Brow Sculpting Mechanical Pencil offers gorgeous and flawless eyebrows with every use. It features a micro-angled tip that delivers a smooth glide finish for maximum precision. The double-edged spoolie brush helps with blending and grooming all kinds of eyebrow shapes. It is smudge-proof and water-resistant for up to 12 hours. Pros
Long-lasting Water-resistant Smudge-proof Cruelty-free (PETA-certified) Available in 5 shades Built-in spoolie
Cons
Might not last long.
9. Best Buildable Coverage:Honest Beauty Eyebrow Pencil
The Honest Beauty Eyebrow Pencil has a soft tip that glides on smoothly for effortless application. Its inbuilt spoolielets you blend sharp lines for soft, natural brows. This pencil delivers fantastic results with its blendable coverage. It is enriched with jojoba seed oil that helps condition and reshapes your brows. Pros
Provides buildable coverage Built-in spoolie Dermatologist-tested Paraben-free Silicone-free Cruelty-free Petrochemical-free Polyethlyene-free
Cons
Requires sharpening
10. Best Hypoallergenic:Mostory Brow Artist Eyebrow Pencil
The Mostory Brow Artist Eyebrow Pencil is available in a 3-in-1 format that combines the good qualities of a pencil, powder, and brush for easy and quick brow filling. It features a custom pencil on one end, a spooled brush on the other, and a sponge-tip applicator primed with brow powder in the center. This hexagonal pencil adds dimension to individual hairs, concealing the over-plucked areas for a uniformly dense look.You can choose from 3 gorgeous shades – auburn, soft brown, and medium brown. Pros
Glides easily Hypoallergenic Non-irritating Cruelty-free Available in 3 shades Dermatologist-tested
Cons
Applicator might wear out quickly.
11. Maybelline Brow Satin Eyebrow Pencil
The Maybelline Brow Satin Eyebrow Pencil gives you smoother, fuller-looking brows at a pocket-friendly price. It is available in 4 shades– blonde, soft brown, medium brown, and deep brown. This 2-in-1 product has a defining pencil to shape your brows and powder to fill in the gaps. It imparts natural-looking brows with a matte finish. Pros
Built-in eyebrow powder Offers a matte finish Long-lasting Available in 4 shades Affordable
Cons
Might break off easily.
12. Keshimei Eyebrow Pencil
The Keshimei Eyebrow Pencil is perfect for daily use. It is smudge, sweat, and water-proof, so your makeup stays in place for a long time. The pencil tip features a 3D triangle design that allows extreme precision for fine eyebrows. The brush end helps manage unruly growth and provides easy blending. It comes in 3 classic shades – light brown, dark brown, and black. Pros
Waterproof Smudge-proof Sweat-proof Easy to blend Easy to remove Value for money Available in 3 shades Non-sharpening
Cons
Not long-lasting.
13. Almay Eyebrow Pencil
The AlmayEyebrow Pencil defines, fills, and tames your brows. This versatile pencil comes in 3 shades–dark blonde, brunette, and universal taupe. It glides on smoothly and stays in place through the wildest of days. This ophthalmologist-tested eyebrow pencil is safe for sensitive eyes. Pros
Long-lasting Smudge-resistant Easy to use Hypoallergenic Available in 3 shades Safe for sensitive eyes Ophthalmologist-tested
Cons
Waxy consistency Might break off easily.
14. Maybelline Brow Precise Micro Eyebrow Pencil
The Maybelline Brow Precise Micro Eyebrow Pencil shapes and styles your brows as you desire. This ultra-precise micro pencil lets you create well-defined brows, while the eyebrow spoolie brush softens harsh lines for a natural look. The ultra-fine 1.5-millimeter retractable tip creates soft, hair-like lines that fill the brows without looking artificial. Pros
Available in 7 shades Retractable micro-tip Inbuilt blending brush Long-lasting Does not flake
Cons
Might crumble easily.
15. NYX Professional Makeup Micro Brow Pencil
The Micro Brow Pencil from NYX Cosmetics provides the precision to build full, beautiful brows. The super skinny tip draws extra fine lines to create natural-looking brow hairs.It is easy to use and is an excellent dupe of Anastasia Beverly Hills’ Brow Wiz. This brow pencil is available in 8 shades. Pros
Long-lasting Inbuilt spoolie Offers a natural finish Cruelty-free Available in 8 shades
Cons
Not smudge-proof
16. Wet N Wild Ultimate Brow Retractable Brow Pencil
This brow pencil from Wet n Wild has a triangular tip that creates fine strokes for a natural finish. It is formulated with rub-resistant pigments that make it last through the longest of days. You also get a spoolie on one side of the pencil to blend out the product. This brow pencil is available in 4 shades – taupe, ash brown, medium brown, and dark brown. Pros
Long-lasting Sweat-resistant Retractable tip Inbuilt spoolie Available in 4 shades
Cons
May tug on the brow hair.
17. Revlon ColorStay Eyebrow Pencil
If youare looking for a drugstore pencil that lasts 24 hours, Revlon’s Colorstay Brow Pencil is a great option. Its angled tip helps you fill in the brows precisely, and its brush tames the wildest of brows for a stunning, sculpted look. This waterproof, drugstore eyebrow pencil comes in 5 shades. Pros
Long-lasting Water-proof Easy to use Inbuilt spoolie Available in 5 shades
Cons
Might smear Might feel greasy
18. iMethod Liquid Eyebrow Pen
This microblading eyebrow pencil features a micro fork tip applicator that helps you create natural-looking brows effortlessly. This smudge-proof formula lasts for 24 hours. It is also waterproof but not tiresome to take off at the end of the day. It glides on smoothly, making it easy to apply. Pros
Available in 4 shades Waterproof Sweat-proof Long-lasting Easy to apply Easy to remove Lifetime warranty
Cons
Might turn blotchy after a while.
19. e.l.f. Essential Instant Lift Brow Pencil
The Instant Lift Brow Pencil from e.l.f is one of the drugstore eyebrow pencils that are suitable for beginners. It shapes, defines, and fills in sparse brows to help you achieve a natural, polished look. This dual-shaped pencil comes with a fine-tip liner on one side, and a spoolie on the other to tame and comb your brows. It is available in 6 shades – taupe, neutral brown, deep brown, blonde, black, and auburn. Pros
Long-lasting Cruelty-free Vegan Available in 6 shades
Cons
Not smudge-proof
20. Music Flower Eyebrow Pencil
The Music Flower Eyebrow Pencil glides on effortlessly to give you soft, natural-looking brows. This retractable pencil delivers a matte finish that lasts up to 8 hours, resisting water and sweat. The other end of the pencil features a highly pigmented, dual-tipped brush that fills sparse gaps and blends sharp lines for a diffused finish. It is available in 4 shades – black, light coffee, khaki coffee, and dark coffee. Pros
Available in 4 shades Long-lasting Waterproof Smudge-proof Sweat-proof
Cons
Might break off easily.
That was our round-up of the 20 best drugstore eyebrow pencils available online. While picking a color for your brow pencil, makeup artists recommend going for a shade lighter than your natural brows for a subtle and soft look. A waxy brow pencil will always help you achieve a realistic finish. Choose your favorite one from our list and flaunt on-fleek eyebrows whenever you step out!
Why Trust StyleCraze?
The author of this article, Sakshi Bahal, is a makeup enthusiast. She has browsed several online forums for user feedback to put together this list of the best drugstore eyebrow pencils for natural-looking brows. Her list contains products that can help you sculpt your pair of brows effortlessly for a naturally fuller look. They are long-lasting, smudge-proof, water-resistant, and glide on easily. Should I go lighter or darker with an eyebrow pencil? Go one shade lighter to match your existing brows. When you cover your eyebrows or draw tiny hair, it may look unnatural if the pencil is too dark or pigmented. What color should my eyebrows be if my hair is gray? Color your eyebrows light brown if your hair is silver or gray. It will make your eyes look distinct and add youthfulness to your look. Can using a drugstore eyebrow pencil help in growing eyebrows? No, eyebrow pencils cannot help you grow actual eyebrows. They offer a temporary fuller look to your brows and fill the barren patches in your eyebrow region. How long does a drugstore eyebrow pencil stay on? Drugstore eyebrow pencils offer a distinct look to your eyebrows throughout the day. They stay on for 12 to 24 hours depending on the weather conditions. Does a dark brown eyebrow pencil suit natural black hair? Yes, definitely. A dark brown eyebrow pencil suits natural black hair. The shade makes your brows look prominent and natural but not overdone. Which drugstore eyebrow pencil can I use for thin eyebrows, brown or black? It depends on your hair color more than the density of your brows. If your hair color is on the lighter side, go for a brown eyebrow pencil. If it is dark, you may go for either a dark brown eyebrow pencil or a black eyebrow pencil. Is eyebrow pencil safe on infants? No, do not use an eyebrow pencil on your infant without checking the ingredients. The pencils may contain lead and zinc which are not suitable for your infant’s sensitive skin and eyes. Can I use a drugstore eyebrow pencil a day after my Lasik surgery? Yes, you may use a drugstore eyebrow pencil the day after a Lasik surgery. However, do not touch your eyes or use any makeup that may flake off and enter your eyes.
Recommended Artilces:
How To Fill In Your Eyebrows Prevent Eyebrow Hair Loss Perfect Eyebrow Shape Ideas For Round Face Shapes
